Skip to main content

The Spectacular by Fiona Davis: A Book Review

 

The Spectacular 

Author: Fiona Davis

Genre: Historical Fiction, Mystery & Suspense

Publisher: Dutton

Release Date: 2023

Pages: 368

Source: Netgalley/Publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Synopsis: From the New York Times Bestselling Author of The Magnolia Palace: A thrilling story about love, sacrifice, and the pursuit of dreams, set amidst the glamour and glitz of Radio City Music Hall in its mid-century heyday.


     New York City, 1956: Nineteen-year-old Marion Brooks knows she should be happy. Her high school sweetheart is about to propose and sweep her off to the life everyone has always expected they’d have together: a quiet house in the suburbs, Marion staying home to raise their future children. But instead, Marion finds herself feeling trapped. So when she comes across an opportunity to audition for the famous Radio City Rockettes—the glamorous precision-dancing troupe—she jumps at the chance to exchange her predictable future for the dazzling life of a performer. 

 

     Meanwhile, the city is reeling from a string of bombings orchestrated by a person the press has nicknamed the “Big Apple Bomber,” who has been terrorizing the citizens of New York for sixteen years by planting bombs in popular, crowded spaces. With the public in an uproar over the lack of any real leads after a years long manhunt, the police turn in desperation to Peter Griggs, a young doctor at a local mental hospital who espouses a radical new technique: psychological profiling. 


     As both Marion and Peter find themselves unexpectedly pulled in to the police search for the bomber, Marion realizes that as much as she’s been training herself to blend in—performing in perfect unison with all the other identical Rockettes—if she hopes to catch the bomber, she’ll need to stand out and take a terrifying risk. In doing so, she may be forced to sacrifice everything she’s worked for, as well as the people she loves the most.


     My Review: Marion is ecstatic to be chosen as a Rockette. However, she learns that becoming a Rockette is not all that she thought it would be. They have four shows a day plus rehearsals. Therefore, it could be very stressful. When the theater is bombed, Marion embarks on a quest to find the bomber. While looking for the bomber, Marion realizes that she may be forced to give up everything that she has worked for. Could Marion make the sacrifice to protect those she loves?



     After reading this book, I came away disliking the main character. Marion is insufferable and a typical Mary Sue. She is perfect at everything and can do no wrong. She comes across more like a superwoman than a real human. Therefore, I could not relate to her. I also did not like that she constantly looked down on others because they were not as perfect as herself. She was also very narcissistic because she was beautiful and could dance. Thus, Marion was one of the most annoying characters that I have ever come across in literature.


     Overall, this novel is about ambition, choices, and sacrifice. I found all of the characters to be flat and stereotypical. The characters are not given any depth and are very cliche. The mystery was interesting, but it was overshadowed by Marion’s drama. There were also some scenes that were so unconvincing that they made me laugh. I did like learning about the Rockettes, however. Those parts were believable and interesting. Nevertheless, I expected a fun, cozy historical mystery. I did not get it, unfortunately, and I was very unsatisfied. I have read other novels by Fiona Davis which are superior to The Spectacular. It feels like she did not put in as much effort as she usually does. I recommend this book for fans of Louise Hare, Emily J. Edwards, and Stephanie Morrill. However, I advise you to read better historical mysteries from this author such as The Magnolia Palace.


Rating: 2 ½ stars out of 5 stars

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Interview with Melanie Karsak

Today, I have the pleasure of having an interview with Melanie Karsak! I have read and enjoyed her many series of books on some of history's more obscure or misunderstood women. Often, little is known about their true histories, either from not being recorded because of their gender and the unimportance given to women or else intentional character assassination. Mrs. Karsak seeks to bring light where much is shrouded in darkness. As a result, we are enriched by their lives and these fascinating women can speak to us through the centuries. In this interview, Mrs. Karsak talks about what drew her to these women and her writing pro cess! Thank you Mrs. Karsak! You have written books on Lady MacBeth, Hervor, Queen Boudica, Queen Cartimandua, and now Freydis. What drew you to write about these women? I like the unsung and maligned heroines. Hervor is a significant character in the Norse Hervarar Saga . In fact, there are two Hervors in that tale—grandmother and granddaughter. But ...

The Body on the Beach (Jane Austen Investigations #4) by Laura Martin: A Book Review

The Body on the Beach (Jane Austen Investigations #4)  Author: Laura Martin Genre: Historical Fiction, Mystery and Suspense Publisher: Sapere Books Book Release Date: 2023 Pages: 239 Source: Borrowed Synopsis: The Austen sisters find themselves embroiled in another murder case! For fans of Georgette Heyer, Mary Balogh, Elizabeth Bailey and Ashley Gardner.      Have a series of murders been covered up…?       1798, Dorset, England        Jane Austen is on holiday with her parents and her sister, enjoying time at the seaside in Lyme Regis.         But one morning, while out on an early stroll, her peace is shattered.       There is someone lying at the bottom of the cliffs.       After rousing her father and sister, she hurries along the beach to find a young woman, dead.     ...

The Girl from Botany Bay by Carolly Erickson: A Book Review

The Girl from Botany Bay Author: Carolly Erickson  Genre: Nonfiction, History, Biography  Publisher: Trade Paper Books Book Release Date: 2008 Pages: 252 Source: Personal Collection  Synopsis: On a moonless night in the early 1790s, prisoner Mary Bryant, her husband William, her two small children, and seven other convicts stole a twenty-foot longboat and slipped noiselessly out of Sydney Cove, Australia, eluding their captors. They sailed north, all the way to Indonesia, traveling some thirty-six hundred treacherous miles in ten weeks—an incredible feat of seamanship. For a time, Mary and her companions were able to convince the local Dutch colonial authorities that they were survivors of a shipwreck, but eventually the truth emerged and they found themselves back in captivity, in irons, on their way to England for execution.       In time, Mary's fateful journey would win her tremendous admiration. A woman once reviled as a criminal w...