Skip to main content

The Girl from Botany Bay by Carolly Erickson: A Book Review

The Girl from Botany Bay

Author: Carolly Erickson 

Genre: Nonfiction, History, Biography 

Publisher: Trade Paper Books

Book Release Date: 2008

Pages: 252

Source: Personal Collection 

Synopsis: On a moonless night in the early 1790s, prisoner Mary Bryant, her husband William, her two small children, and seven other convicts stole a twenty-foot longboat and slipped noiselessly out of Sydney Cove, Australia, eluding their captors.


They sailed north, all the way to Indonesia, traveling some thirty-six hundred treacherous miles in ten weeks—an incredible feat of seamanship. For a time, Mary and her companions were able to convince the local Dutch colonial authorities that they were survivors of a shipwreck, but eventually the truth emerged and they found themselves back in captivity, in irons, on their way to England for execution.


      In time, Mary's fateful journey would win her tremendous admiration. A woman once reviled as a criminal would become a London celebrity, ultimately finding forgiveness and freedom.


         In The Girl from Botany Bay, distinguished historian and biographer Carolly Erickson tells Mary Bryant's remarkable story at full length for the first time—the story of a woman whose impoverished Cornwall childhood led to a life of outlaw daring and thievery, then to harsh imprisonment and exile. Erickson recounts Mary's bold ventures from her point of view, beginning with her conviction and death sentence for highway robbery. Reprieved, she was sent to New South Wales to serve out her time, one of dozens of female convicts chosen as sexual companions for the hundreds of male convicts destined for settlement in the remote continent of Australia.


        From Mary's perilous sea journey to Botany Bay and Sydney Cove, to the inhuman conditions at the penal colony, to the risky escape to the Indonesian island of Timor and the horrors of the sail back to England—during which Mary's husband and two children died of disease—the story is harrowing yet heroic. With the dramatic narrative skill for which she is acclaimed, Erickson brings Mary and her companions to life in compelling detail. All the dangers of seafaring adventure are here: violent storms, near drownings, severe hunger and thirst, and the perils of relentless exposure to sun, wind, and salt spray that left the convicts with their skin scraped raw and their strength leached away.


       When she finally landed in England and testified before the magistrate's court, Mary was magnificent in her own defense. No one had the heart to condemn her; had she not, through her suffering, paid for her crimes? Impressed by Mary's sturdy self-possession and courage, lawyer and author James Boswell came to her rescue, ensuring that "the Girl from Botany Bay," as the newspapers called her, was freed and able to begin a new life.


         The epic story of Mary Bryant, the brave and resourceful girl from Botany Bay, is compelling narrative nonfiction at its very best.


       My Review: The Girl from Botany Bay is a biography of Mary Bryant. She was the most successful convict to escape the Australian penal colony. There have been numerous movies, television series, and plays on her. In this biography, Mary Bryant’s name was originally Mary Broad. She was a highway robber and was sentenced to live in Australia. However, Mary would eventually escape and make her way back to England.


        I have never heard of Mary Bryant before. However, I found her to be a very fascinating figure. Mary had suffered much hardship on the journey to Australia. During the journey, Mary had a daughter with a man named Mr. Spence. When Mary arrived, she married a fellow convict and a veteran seaman named William Bryant. The marriage was not serious. She bore him a son named Emmanuel. Together, they planned their escape from Australia. They used a fishing boat and after sixty-nine days, they reached Kupang. Once they reached Kupang, William and Mary had an argument. William then betrayed Mary and was recaptured by the British. Mary’s husband and children died on the way back to Britain. Once Mary arrived in England, her story fascinated the English, especially James Boswell. He helped secure her freedom. Therefore, I could not help but find Mary to be a fascinating and a strong historical figure.


      Overall, this was a very comprehensive and engaging biography. I thought that Mrs. Erickson did an excellent job in showing the hardships of living in the penal colony of Australia. There were times that I thought that she speculated a great deal on what Mary Bryant was thinking and feeling. Nevertheless, I still found it to be a very easy and light read! It illuminated my understanding of a historical figure that I knew nothing about. The Girl from Botany Bay was a very thrilling and captivating story! I was entranced by the book from the very first page! I recommend this book for fans of A Cargo of Women, Fair Game, and The Tin Ticket!


Rating: 4 out of 5 stars


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Blue Butterfly: A Novel of Marion Davies by Leslie Johansen Nack

The Blue Butterfly: A Novel of Marion Davies Author: Leslie Johansen Nack Genre: Historical Fiction Publisher: She Writes Press Release Date: May 3rd, 2022 Pages: 352 Source: This book was given to me by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Synopsis: New York 1915, Marion Davies is a shy eighteen-year-old beauty dancing on the Broadway stage when she meets William Randolph Hearst and finds herself captivated by his riches, passion and desire to make her a movie star. Following a whirlwind courtship, she learns through trial and error to live as Hearst’s mistress when a divorce from his wife proves impossible. A baby girl is born in secret in 1919 and they agree to never acknowledge her publicly as their own. In a burgeoning Hollywood scene, she works hard making movies while living a lavish partying life that includes a secret love affair with Charlie Chaplin. In late 1937, at the height of the depression, Hearst wrestles with his debtors and failing health, when Marion loan...

Cover Reveal of A Founding Mother by Stephanie Dray and Laura Kamoie

I’m so excited that People Magazine just revealed this gorgeous new cover for the upcoming historical novel, A FOUNDING MOTHER about the amazing Abigail Adams, coming May 5, 2026 from my friends Stephanie Dray and Laura Kamoie! This is going to be the perfect way to celebrate Mother’s Day and to commemorate the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence! Let me know what you think of the cover! ✭✭✭ Coming 5/5/26! PRE-ORDER NOW ✭✭✭ You can also pre-order on Amazon , Apple , Audible , Barnes and Noble , Books-A-Million , Bookshop.org , GooglePlay , and Kobo ! You can also add the book to your Goodreads and Bookbub ! ✭✭✭ ABOUT THE BOOK ✭✭✭ In time for the 250th Anniversary of the birth of the United States comes a sweeping, intimate portrayal of Abigail Adams—wife of one president and mother to another—whose wit, willpower and wisdom helped shape the fledgling republic. A stunning historical novel with modern-day implications from the New York Times bestselling autho...

Guest Post by Elisa DeCarlo: From Corsets to Chemises: Fashion as Liberation

  Today's guest writer is Elisa DeCarlo. Elisa DeCarlo has published two novels, Strong Spirits and The Devil You Say as well as The Abortionist's Daughter . Her work is also in a number of anthologies. Elisa has also written and performed a number of solo shows across the country. In 2013, the Exit Press will publish an anthology of her stage work. Elisa was born in Westchester, NY, and grew up there and in New York City. As an actress, she has performed in television, radio and film. In her guest post, Elisa DeCarlo talks women's fashion in the 1910s. Be sure to check out my review of The Abortionist's Daughter soon. Thank you, Mrs. DeCarlo. From Corsets to Chemises: Fashion As Liberation In The Abortionist’s Daughter , which is set in 1916, the evolution of the main character, Melanie Daniels, is not only shown by her thoughts actions, but also her clothes.  Since I am an obsessed fashion buff, I had to write about the clothes! Queen Victoria ...