Skip to main content

Interview With David Cataletto

     Today, I have the pleasure of interviewing author, David Cataletto. He is the author of Kings of the Coast, Montauk, which tells the story of a Native American princess who was kidnapped in New York in the 1660s. In this interview, we discussed why this event was forgotten in history. We also discussed his writing process and which parts of the book were true and which parts he used creative license. Thank you, Mr. Cataletto!



What inspired you to write Kings of the Coast? 

I teach middle school history and English so wanted to teach my students about our incredible and dynamic history of Long Island, New York.   



The story of Storm Lily, who was a Native American princess being kidnapped in 1660s New York, is largely forgotten. Why do you think the story is forgotten?  

I think it happened so long ago and so much has changed that it might seem irrelevant to today's youth. Also, there is not much written evidence from this time period. 

Why is Storm Lilly not a famous Native American princess like Pocahontas?  

Great question! Again, I think it's because the story has been lost in time and not well known. 

Kings of the Coast is told from the perspectives of Seahawk and Storm Lilly. Why did you decide to tell the story from their perspectives?

At first I wrote it from the perspective of Seahawk. But then I thought about how half my students are female, and I wanted them to have a character they could identify with and be empowered by. I thought about also having a few chapters from David's POV but thought it might get to messy.   

What parts of The Kings Coast were based on fact and which ones were fictional?  

So, Lion Gardiner, David Gardiner and the origin of Gardiner's Island are accurate. Also Sachem Wyandanch of the Montauketts was real as was his daughter. She was actually kidnapped from her wedding and eventually returned to Montauket. Also, the feud between the Dutch and English for New York did happen. Although there wasn't a real battle, I created that to add drama.  I created the character of Seahawk and the other Montauketts like Ten Bears, Gray Wolf, Bright Water, etc. 

What was your research process like? What sources did you use for your research?   

I give lots of local history talks at our local libraries and historical societies so I've been doing lots of research at our library, going over old archives, journals, history books, etc. Plus online searches. 

What were the most challenging aspects of writing Kings of the Coast?  

I think it was trying to keep the pace moving and interesting so YA audience don't get bored.  Also, knowing when it was done, I kept wanting to add more layers and details to the narrative. 

Were there any facts during your research that were surprising to you?  

Not sure since I've always loved this era and history and have been researching it for many years. 

What is your next project?  

Hopefully enough people read and enjoy Kings of the Coast: Montauk, so I plan on writing a second book. Maybe titled Kings of the Coast, King Philips' War. Not sure exactly. Or maybe a book on haunted tales from Montauk.  

About David Cataletto:

       David Cataletto is an East Hampton native and a dedicated educator, teaching History and English at East Hampton Middle School. There, he channels student energy into local causes by running two community service clubs: Surfrider and Do Good Be Good.

       Beyond the classroom, David is engaged in the preservation and stewardship of East Hampton. He currently serves as an East Hampton Town Trustee, chairs the Education Committee at the historic Amagansett Life-Saving Station Museum, and is a Trustee for the East Hampton Town Nature Preserve Committee.

        David leads a sea shanty band that performs at historical events and dive bars. In the summer, he sails around New England with his wife and two young kids on their sailboat. For more information please visit his website.

If you are interested in purchasing Kings of the Coast: Montauk, you can purchase it through Amazon!

Also, check out my review of Kings of the Coast: Montauk!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Presidentess: The Life of First Lady Julia Gardiner by Christopher J. Leahy and Sharon Williams Leahy: A Book Review

  Presidentess: The Life of First Lady Julia Gardiner Author: Christopher J. Leahy & Sharon Williams Leahy Genre: Nonfiction, History, Biography  Publisher: University Press of Kansas Publication Date: September 29, 2026 Pages: 573 Source: This book was given to me by the publicist in exchange for an honest review. Synopsis: The first full biography of the controversial and complex First Lady Julia Gardiner Tyler—an unjustly scandalized New Yorker, the second wife to President John Tyler, and a savvy and consequential political figure in the age of the Civil War.         Myths, rumors, and gossip have long circulated around First Lady Julia Gardiner Tyler. Commonly believed to be politically insignificant, most of our fascination with Tyler surrounds her reputation as a highly desired superficial flirt. This salacious mythos was based on her status in a politically influential New York family and the popular rumor that she posed for ...

The Intimate Afterlife of Myth: Ancient Stories for the Inner Life by Venus Gunyeli: A Book Review

The Intimate Afterlife of Myth: Ancient Stories for the Inner Life Author: Venus Gunyeli Genre: Nonfiction, History, Biography, Religion, Mythology Publisher: Venus Gunyeli Book Release Date: August 14, 2026 Pages: 132 Source: This book was given to me by the author in exchange for an honest review. Synopsis : MYTH IS NOT OVER.         It survives in the choices we repeat, the losses we carry, and the questions that return when certainty gives way.         What if the figures of myth were not distant symbols, but lives we could approach more closely—lives shaped by love and loyalty, power and error, grief and change?         The Intimate Afterlife of Myth revisits ten Greek and Mesopotamian myths, from Persephone and Gilgamesh to Inanna, Psyche, Hector, and Prometheus. Rather than reducing them to simple lessons or fixed interpretations, the book stays with the psychologi...

Interview with Christopher Leahy and Sharon Williams Leahy

      Today, I have the pleasure of interviewing Christopher Leahy and Sharon Williams Leahy. They have recently published  Presidentess , which is a biography of First Lady Julia Gardiner Tyler. In this interview, we discussed why Julia Gardiner Tyler was considered America's most controversial First Lady. We also discussed what impact Julia Gardiner Tyler played in shaping the role of First Lady. Thank you, Mr. and Mrs. Leahy! Why is Julia Gardiner Tyler considered a controversial First Lady? Sharon: Julia was a woman of striking contradictions. She was innovative and influential as First Lady, but after her time in the White House, she adapted to the slaveholding society of Virginia. She publicly pushed back against British criticism of the American slave system.  During the Civil War, her private correspondence also reveals strong Confederate sympathies.  We wanted to tell the whole story of her accomplishments, as well as the beliefs and choices that ...