Skip to main content

The Unfaithful Queen: A Novel of Henry VIII's Fifth Wife by Carolly Erickson: A Book Review

The Unfaithful Queen: A Novel of Henry VIII's Fifth Wife

Author: Carolly Erickson

Genre: Historical Fiction

Publisher: St. Martin’s Press

Release Date: 2012

Pages: 302

Source: My State Public Library 

Synopsis: From New York Times bestselling author of The Last Wife of Henry VIII, a novel about Catherine Howard, wife of Henry's later years.


     Amid the turbulent, faction-ridden late reign of the fearsome Henry, eager high-spirited Catherine Howard caught the king's eye—but not before she had been the sensual plaything of at least three other men. Ignorant of her past, seeing only her youthful exuberance and believing that she could make him happy, he married her—only to discover, too late, that her heart belonged to his gentleman usher Tom Culpeper. 


     As the net of court intrigue tightens around her, and with the Tudor succession yet again in peril because of Prince Edward's severe illness, Queen Catherine struggles to give the angry, bloated and impotent king a son. But when her relations turn against her, she finds herself doomed, just as her cousin Anne Boleyn was, to face the executioner.


     The Unfaithful Queen lays bare the dark underbelly of the Tudor court, with its sugared rivalries and bitter struggles for power, where a girl of noble family could find herself sent to labor among the turnspits in the kitchens or—should fortune favor her—be exalted to the throne.


     My Review: Catherine Howard was the fifth Queen of Henry VIII. She had an affair with Thomas Culpepper and was executed for treason. In this novel, Catherine catches the eye of King Henry VIII. However, her heart belongs to Tom Culpepper. Once Catherine becomes queen, she is plagued with many troubles. She struggles to give the king a healthy son. Yet, Queen Catherine tries to hide her dark past that threatens to be revealed to the king.


     I really like Queen Catherine Howard. I found her to be a tragic and sympathetic character. She was a pawn to be used by her powerful uncle. Yet, when she was in trouble her uncle abandoned her. I also found it sad that her life was not her own. She wanted to marry for love, but was forced by her family and her love to marry the king. Queen Catherine also had many enemies who eagerly awaited her downfall. Therefore, Queen Catherine was a naive and trusting person. However, I like how Mrs. Erickson portrayed Catherine’s marriage to Henry. Queen Catherine had to give Henry another prince. Because of her failure, the king began to tire of her. Queen Catherine becomes insecure and desperate. She hopes that by having a son will secure her position even if the son is not her husband’s. Thus, Queen Catherine makes many foolish choices that lead her to the execution block. I wished that Queen Catherine would have made better decisions so that her ending would have been different.


     Overall, this novel is about choices, power, and love. I found all of the characters to be very flawed but realistic. I especially enjoyed the rivalry between Queen Anne of Cleves and Queen Catherine Howard. I also liked how it begins with Queen Catherine’s cousin, Queen Anne Boleyn’s execution. This seemed to foreshadow Queen Catherine’s fate! There were a few things I did not like about this book. There were some inaccuracies and some of the scenes seemed far-fetched. Nevertheless, I was enthralled by The Unfaithful Queen from the first page. It was very suspenseful! It also reads like a soap opera! It had danger, romance, and political and courtly intrigue! I believe this is Mrs. Erickson’s best historical fiction novel that she has written! I recommend this for fans of A Rose Without a Thorn, Katheryn Howard: The Scandalous Queen, and The King’s Rose!


Rating: 4 out of 5 stars


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Lady of Lincoln (The Nicola de la Haye Series #1) by Rachel Elwiss Joyce: A Book Review

Lady of Lincoln (The Nicola de la Haye Series #1) Author: Rachel Elwiss Joyce Genre: Historical Fiction, Romance Publisher: Hedgehog Books  Book Release Date: February 27, 2026 Pages: 464 Source: Netgalley/Publisher in exchange for an honest review. Synopsis: A true story. A forgotten heroine. In a time when women were told to stay silent, could she become the saviour her people need?      12th-century England. Nicola de la Haye wants to do her duty. But though she’s taught a female cannot lead alone, the young noblewoman bristles at the marriage her father has arranged to secure her inheritance. And when an unexpected death leaves her unguided, the impetuous girl shuns the king’s blessing and weds a handsome-but-landless knight.         Harshly fined by Henry II for her unsanctioned union, Nicola struggles to salvage her estates while dealing with devastating betrayals from her husband… and his choice to join rebels...

Interview with Meihan Boey

       Today, I have the pleasure of interviewing author, Meihan Boey. She is the author of The Formidable Miss Cassidy , which is the first novel in the Miss Cassidy trilogy. The first novel is about how a Scottish governess helps her employer's family who is haunted by a malevolent spirit. She has recently released, The Enigmatic Madam Ingram , which is the second novel in the  trilogy. In this interview, we discussed not only her latest novel, but also Singaporean mythology. Thank you, Mrs. Boey! What inspired you to write The Formidable Miss Cassidy ? Did you know it would be a trilogy before you started writing or did it form while you were writing it?  Yes, I did know I wanted to create a trilogy - I just didn’t know at the start whether or not I would be able to get there!  The Formidable Miss Cassidy started life as a COVID project, sent as a short story to a little Canadian indie press. Because I didn’t think a typical Canadian audience was go...

Lady of the Castle (The Nicole de la Haye Series #2) by Rachel Elwiss Joyce: A Book Review

Lady of the Castle (The Nicola de la Haye Series #2) Author: Rachel Elwiss Joyce Genre: Historical Fiction, Romance Publisher: Hedgehog Books  Book Release Date: September 21, 2026 Pages: 598 Source: This book was given to me by the author in exchange for an honest review. Synopsis : For a woman, holding power in a man's world is dangerous; holding faith in an intolerant one is deadly.        England, 1185. Nicola de la Haye, constable of Lincoln Castle, commands her fortress with hard-won authority. Determined to protect her family from a kingdom fracturing around her, she discovers the hardest battle is the one inside her own walls.       When the king's chancellor marches an army to her gates and her husband stands accused of treason, Nicola must hold her castle against a siege—and hold her family together against something far harder to fight. As her marriage buckles under the weight of loss, jealousy, and the gho...