Skip to main content

Pardonable Lies (Maisie Dobbs #3) by Jacqueline Winspear: A Book Review

Pardonable Lies (Maisie Dobbs #3)
Author: Jacqueline Winspear
Genre: Historical Fiction, Mystery 
Publisher: Picador
Release Date: 2006
Pages: 384
Source: My State Public Library
 Synopsis: London 1930, psychologist investigator Maisie Dobbs must prove Sir Cedric's aviator son Ralph Lawton died when shot down in 1917. In former battlefields of France, she re-unites with Priscilla Evernden, one of whose three brothers lost in the War is somehow connected. The case tests Maisie's spiritual strength and her regard for mentor Maurice Blanche.

      My Review: Maisie Dobbs is hired by Sir Cedric to find evidence that his son, Ralph Lawton, has been killed in the war. The case leads her to France, where her best friend Priscilla also asks her to find her brother’s lost grave. As Maisie journeys to France, she finds that the two cases are connected. As she delves deeper into the mysteries surrounding these two lost soldiers, Maisie begins to question her mentor, Maurice, with whom she holds in the highest regard.

     The cases for Maisie were tough on Her emotionally. Maisie follows their trail to France, where it forced her to remember the horrors she experienced as a nurse in WWI. Thus, this storyline was very fascinating to me because while Maisie is tough on the outside, she is still a very vulnerable woman who is suffering from the effects of the war. Therefore, Maisie was a very relatable woman that I could connect to. There were some parts that I didn’t like about her. She seemed to be avoiding her boyfriend, who generally seemed very concerned for her. I didn’t like the way she treated him, for she was very mean to him. Maisie could also have been unforgiving at times. Still, despite these unfavorable aspects of her character, Maisie seemed more sympathetic.

      Overall, this book shows the trauma and after effects of WWI for all those involved. While Maisie was well-rounded, I would have liked more development of the supporting characters, such as Maurice and Andrew. I also thought the mysteries were predictable. However, I found Priscilla's to be more intriguing than Sir Cedric’s case. So far, these mysteries have been very compelling. The only thing that I don’t like about the series is how she solves the cases. She doesn’t solve them through logic, but through spiritualism. It feels very modern to me and a very lazy form of writing for Maisie to use her imagination of what happened to solve the cases. Despite this concern, I can’t wait to read the fourth book in the Maisie Dobbs series, Messenger of Truth. 
Rating: 3 out of 5 stars


 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Presidentess: The Life of First Lady Julia Gardiner by Christopher J. Leahy and Sharon Williams Leahy: A Book Review

  Presidentess: The Life of First Lady Julia Gardiner Author: Christopher J. Leahy & Sharon Williams Leahy Genre: Nonfiction, History, Biography  Publisher: University Press of Kansas Publication Date: September 29, 2026 Pages: 573 Source: This book was given to me by the publicist in exchange for an honest review. Synopsis: The first full biography of the controversial and complex First Lady Julia Gardiner Tyler—an unjustly scandalized New Yorker, the second wife to President John Tyler, and a savvy and consequential political figure in the age of the Civil War.         Myths, rumors, and gossip have long circulated around First Lady Julia Gardiner Tyler. Commonly believed to be politically insignificant, most of our fascination with Tyler surrounds her reputation as a highly desired superficial flirt. This salacious mythos was based on her status in a politically influential New York family and the popular rumor that she posed for ...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Intimate Afterlife of Myth: Ancient Stories for the Inner Life by Venus Gunyeli: A Book Review

The Intimate Afterlife of Myth: Ancient Stories for the Inner Life Author: Venus Gunyeli Genre: Nonfiction, History, Biography, Religion, Mythology Publisher: Venus Gunyeli Book Release Date: August 14, 2026 Pages: 132 Source: This book was given to me by the author in exchange for an honest review. Synopsis : MYTH IS NOT OVER.         It survives in the choices we repeat, the losses we carry, and the questions that return when certainty gives way.         What if the figures of myth were not distant symbols, but lives we could approach more closely—lives shaped by love and loyalty, power and error, grief and change?         The Intimate Afterlife of Myth revisits ten Greek and Mesopotamian myths, from Persephone and Gilgamesh to Inanna, Psyche, Hector, and Prometheus. Rather than reducing them to simple lessons or fixed interpretations, the book stays with the psychologi...
Post a Comment
Read more

Interview with Christopher Leahy and Sharon Williams Leahy

      Today, I have the pleasure of interviewing Christopher Leahy and Sharon Williams Leahy. They have recently published  Presidentess , which is a biography of First Lady Julia Gardiner Tyler. In this interview, we discussed why Julia Gardiner Tyler was considered America's most controversial First Lady. We also discussed what impact Julia Gardiner Tyler played in shaping the role of First Lady. Thank you, Mr. and Mrs. Leahy! Why is Julia Gardiner Tyler considered a controversial First Lady? Sharon: Julia was a woman of striking contradictions. She was innovative and influential as First Lady, but after her time in the White House, she adapted to the slaveholding society of Virginia. She publicly pushed back against British criticism of the American slave system.  During the Civil War, her private correspondence also reveals strong Confederate sympathies.  We wanted to tell the whole story of her accomplishments, as well as the beliefs and choices that ...
1 comment
Read more